Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Everything Explained

For some reason I've received a number of visitors to my blog looking for the meaning of this song. Being a gracious host I will now explain it. This is what the song means, the Gospel of Trapeze Artistry according to Shawn.

First, let's talk about Trapeze Swingers. This is a dangerous job; it's not suited for everyone; if everyone gave it a try we'd have many more dead and injured people on our hands. Second, this song isn't a story so much as a mood. You can traverse it from point A to point B without reaching the destination. Thirdly, it's a song about Trapeze Swingers, not clowns or bankers. There's a place for clowns and bankers in life, but that place is NOT high above a crowd with no nets to catch them when they fall. Remember that.

Please, remember meHappily
From the get go we're told something has ended. We'll be reminded frequently. The story teller's real desire is to be remembered in some positive manner.

By the rosebush laughingWith bruises on my chinThe time whenWe counted every black car passingYour house beneath the hillAnd up untilSomeone caught us in the kitchenWith maps, a mountain range,A piggy bankA vision too removed to mention
Here's some examples of the good times, one can be happy for these can't they? The speaker seems to think so. The second half is the more interesting part. To the casual observer (one who catches them in the kitchen) it's all vague, like a map, mountain rangers, a piggy bank and visions that the observer couldn't understand even if they could see more than the maps and piggy banks.

Please, remember me
Fondly
Don't forget.

I heard from someone you're still pretty
Ouch, but he probably knew that already. More to the point, it's been long enough since they've seen each other that their physical appearances could have changed.

And then
They went on to say
That the pearly gates
Had some eloquent graffiti
Like 'We'll meet again'
And 'Fuck the man'

And 'Tell my mother not to worry'

This bit is harder to decode. I'm not sure the person actually said these things. Here's my suspicion, they said, "she's still pretty," and then the poor fellow is lost in his own thoughts. And these are the words he heard. We'll Meet Again. A Trapeze Swinger finds it hard to give up the heights. Fuck the man. And all the things he says are impossible. Tell my mother not not to worry. Even in your lowest of times you can't help but worry about mom.

And angels with their gray
Handshakes

Were always done in such a hurry

I'm not sure what the importance of the color gray is here, but I can imagine that if you get to touch an angel, that moment of contact will always feel way too short.

Please, remember me
At Halloween

There's really no better time of year.

Making fools of all the neighbors
Our faces painted white

See they're still having some good times. They can still make each other laugh. But the problem is, as we'll see later, they've given up their Trapeze Swinger outfits and are running around dressed as clowns, or ghosts of their former selves.

By midnight
We'd forgotten one another

And when the morning came

I was ashamed

And here it is, the beginning of the end.

Only now it seems so silly
Hindsight is 20/20: of course he shouldn't have forgotten her at halloween.

That season left the world
And then returned

And now you're lit up by the city

Things change and remain the same, but mostly they changed. Even so, it's true, she's still beautiful.

Please, remember me
Mistakenly

He wasn't perfect. Let's not make that mistake.

Disclaimer (I know, a little late): Now that I'm sitting here trying to figure out what's exactly meant I can understand why people searched the Internet to figure it out. I don't feel comfortable with the next couple parts but it's the best I could do. We'll see if I was really up to the challenge.

In the window of the tallest tower call
Then pass us by

But much too high

To see the empty road at happy hour

Leave and resonate

Just like the gates

Around the holy kingdom

With words like 'Lost and Found' and 'Don't Look Down'

And 'Someone Save Temptation'

Sometimes there are problems with too much height. You get way up there and you can't see things you use to be able to see, some of the missing things are simple, like happy hour, others are complex, like the gates that guard the holy kingdom. Then you realize you're not actually that high, but you would have known that long ago if you hadn't put so much stock in the words you found "up" there: "Lost and Found" and "Don't Look Down."

Please, remember me
As in the dream
This comes off as desperation. Just remember the good parts, not all the time, but every once in awhile.

We had as rug-burned babies
Among the fallen trees

And fast asleep

Aside the lions and the ladies

That called you what you like

And even might

Give a gift for your behavior

A fleeting chance to see

A trapeze

Swing as high as any savior

Here he tries to convince her that it was really worth it. It was worth flying. And in a perfect dreamy world perhaps they could have lived aside the lions and the ladies and the heights would have been a savior. But it's a dream, he's already admitted that, and she won't be taken in by it

Please, remember me
My misery

This is different. What does he want? Pity? It's tainting the goodness of all his other memories. Maybe this is where desperation leads. His thinking of the impossible good leads him to misery. Maybe.

And how it lost me all I wanted
It seems to be something else. Had he been happier back then, not because of her, but life, then perhaps things would have been different. Perhaps his misery and sadness drove her away? This is speculation as it does not sound like a trapeze swinger.

Those dogs that love the rain
And chasing trains

The colored birds above there running

In circles round the well

It's hard to make heads or tails of this since the previous line left me scratching my head. These are dangerous activities, much like trapeze swinging. Perhaps there is a certain sadness to the danger a trapeze swinger requires?

And where it spells
On the wall behind St. Peter's
So bright with cinder gray
And spray paint
'Who the hell can see forever?'
And no matter what it is, how good it could have been, or how bad it could have been, or how good it is, or how bad it is, it's still a gamble. We're all trapeze swingers to some small degree, because the answer to the question is "No one."

Please, remember me
Seldomly
He Knows he's been asking too much. Remembering isn't always a walk in the park.

In the car behind the carnival
My hand between your knees
You turn from me
And said 'The trapeze act was wonderful
But never meant to last'
The clown that passed
Saw me just come up with anger
When it filled with circus dogs
The parking lot
Had an element of danger
Here we are, back in real life. The end of it. The final act. He offers her a physical--if not loving at this point--touch, and she can't bare to look at him. All she knows is the the heights were wonderful, but they weren't meant to last. And all of the sudden they were both alone and vulnerable to the world, so much so that the parking lot filled with clowns and ordinary people feels dangerous--no high-wires required.


Please, remember me
Finally
Seriously, he's done trying. Things are what they are.

And all my uphill clawing
My dear
He did try pretty hard, but the hill was too steep, or his claws weren't strong enough or sharp enough.

But if i make
The pearly gates

Do my best to make a drawing

Of God and Lucifer

A boy and girl

An angel kissin on a sinner

A monkey and a man

A marching band

All around the frightened trapeze swingers

I don't know what this means. I'll leave it to my readers to tell me what it means. Please leave a comment.

27 comments:

Brad Wing-Quay said...

Thankyou so much for this. It's very interesting to read someone's take on this song and have them go into such depth. This is one of my favourite songs and, like a lot of people, i've been quite confused by some of the parts in this song.

But boy, what a beautiful song. It truly is astounding songwriting... at its best.

Thanks again,
Brad

Anonymous said...

dude you're completely wrong about the the part about him getting in his thought having to do with the pearly gate line. This song is about him doing his childhood friend wrong. And the line "and they went on to say..." denotes that he is dead because he is talking to someone who has seen the gates ergo, dead. i didnt bother reading the rest.

Shawn said...

You might be correct.

But on the downside you've destroyed my illusion about how anyone who listens to Iron and Wine can't possibly be rude or mean.

So it goes.

Stasis Edit said...

I dig that you atemtped to spell out the meaning of this song. I've thought about writing about it myself, if only just so I'd have a stronger grip on what so pulls me to this sone, but never have. I do think we have different takes on this song, entirely, but I didn't really think someone would have such a different understanding of this song than I do. I like that. Adds to the songs dimension.

Unknown said...

This is a very existential song I think... I have a hard time figuring it out. Thanks for your comments on it! I think this last part is especially important - that we are all trapeze swingers. We are all on that rope (life), swinging (through our time, our existance). And eventually, we have to let go of the bar - we die and fly into the unknown.

We are all trapeze swingers, but we want to pretend that we aren't. We all want to pretend that life is not so ephemeral and short. We want to avoid thinking about our death and our existence.

But this song is reminding us.

MChanler89 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
StefanPaulGeorge said...

My thoughts are that the image of the trapeze act is a metaphor for their relationship. Obviously they are not together when he wrote this. She says the trapeze act is wonderful but never meant to last. The beginning of the song is him thinking back on all the times they shared. I don't emphasis should be put on every word after please remember me. These only separate different memories and thoughts he has of the two of them. I think when he says "please remember my misery and how it lost me all I wanted those dogs...." he is saying he was miserable in his up hill clawing and trying to make things work but he didn't realize how miserable he was because he loved it. "My dear but if I make the pearly gates" I believe to mean that if I am right, or if god see's my time as well spent, "I'll to my best to make a drawing of god and Lucifer, a boy and girl, and angel kissing on a sinner" He will still see her as an angel and him as wrong. all these images surround the "frightened trapeze swinger" at the end. If he see's her as an angel, if he sees her as right, then her thought of the trapeze swinger never meant to last will be what he sees. Freightened because they are never meant to last. much like the relationship he built up in the first part of the song. So if one questioned the images of someone saying she's still pretty and then going on to talk about the pearly gates, we can most likely see that that someone is in fact him, in heaven, seeing she is still pretty, she is still an angel.

Anonymous said...

Thank you very much for posting your thoughts on this song. Since I heard The Trapeze Swinger on Austin City Limits a few months ago it's been like a drug to me but I haven't figured out exactly what he means. Thanks for providing your insight.

Anonymous said...

i lost an 18yr old boyfriend to suicide. he suffered depression, but was the sweetest most fun soul i'd ever met. this song speaks to me as a boy whos saying the things he wanted to to the girl he left behind, 'my misery, how it lost me all i wanted' and 'tell my mother not to worry' all sounds like lines from someone who took their own life. thank you for sharing your opinion.

Tracy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Tracy said...

I agree with anon (but not so rudely) that the quotes "we'll meet again" and "fuck the man" and "tell my mother not to worry" are suppose to be literally written on the pearly gates. So, either the speaker is dead OR the girl is dead and the speaker has visions (a dream or something) where another dead person comes to hime to give an update from the afterlife. I def think that is what is up with the references to the pearly gate and the reason for their seperation. I also think that what the other "anon" poster said about the suicide could explain a lot. He is singing to her after he dies. The obscure references aren't meant to be understood fully or explained away. This is an intimate song and the obscure references that sometimes seem to us not to fully connect or make sense are meant to create the feeling of spying into two lovers initimate moments--referencing personal experiences that only the two of them understand--much like it is when you read someone else's yearbook and have no idea what the rememberances are all about; but, you sense the friendship of the writer and the owner of the yearbook. It is like, "Wow, those two had something really special" and it is in the tone of the passage, not in understanding the references. That is the feeling I get from this song. Some of it is literal, but much of it is intimate shared memories that we can only get a sense of--not a literal or symbolic meaning from. For what it is worth--that is my take.

Tracy said...

Yeah, rereading--I def think he is dead (suicude makes sense but not definate) and he is sorting out his life in some sort of waiting place (purgatory?)and having a hard time moving on because he needs closure eith his girl. He converses with souls who have seen the "pearly gates" and can see her on earth too--perhaps who have already passed over.

Shawn said...

I sort of love that this is the only reason people come to my blog. :) Thanks for your thoughts. You all are probably correct that death has a bigger part in the song than I give it "credit" for in my analysis.

Anonymous said...

The last part, I think he's talking about Heaven. I think he's dead, and the pearly gates are the gates of Heaven. He is trying to get into Heaven, and he says that if he does get there, he will try to describe/draw what he might see there: God, Lucifer, boy, girl, angels, sinners, etc.

Tracy said...

I think you are right about him making the drawing as he is about to enter heaven and I see it as his last message to the world before he passes through the gates. In his case, his last message to his girl. However, I see it not as what he sees there; but, as what he remembers and is leaving as a sign to her when she arrives. It is the closure and enlightenment that he came to while waiting to be ready to leave the "waiting place" from which he composes the rest of the song. All of the messages throoughout the song which have been written on the gates are messages of closure. His closure is letting the girl know he wants to be remembered and that she meant everything to him. They are the "boy and girl" and she is the "angel kissing on a sinner". He wants her to recognize the drawing of things they experienced together so she will know that is where he is waiting for her. He can't pass through without knowing she will recognize that he has left his mark behind as a way to be sure she can find him again when it is her time.

JD said...

This song makes me cry every time I give it a good listen.

I see the narrator as a ghost or a soul in some sort of purgatory who is on the brink letting go and moving to the next step, which he thinks of as a cliche version of heaven.

There are three characteristics of a trapeze swinger that are used throughout the song: swinging, being up high, and being colorful like a circus.

Like a trapeze swinger, he takes comfort in going perpetually back and forth, without the finality of an ending. He mentions several examples in the memories he wants his friend/lover to recall. "That season left the world and then returned." Autumn signals death but spring always comes again. The Halloween costumes in which they had "forgotten one another" seemed silly when morning came. Other cyclical words/phrases are: "we'll meet again," "Lost and Found,and "running in circles round the well."

Also like a trapeze swinger, he takes comfort in being up high. He likes things that are out of focus or out of reach because they seem to lack the finality that he dreads. The far away road at happy hour "leaves" but it was okay because it was too far away to see clearly. He likes the memory of childhood quest with the piggy bank and the map, because the final destination was "too removed to mention." Cars and trains can flit by and it's okay because he can't see where they end.

Cleverly, there are several words/phrases chosen for their locations (either being up high or down low, like heaven or earth.) Low: rug-burned, empty road, parking lot, below the hill, fallen trees, and rose bush. High: much too high, tallest tower, hill, mountain range, don't look down, swing as high, and birds above there.

A trapeze swinger would be drawn to color like the neon graffiti paint or colorful birds. To the narrator, things representing death are bleak and monochromatic. Such as black cars, white Halloween (death) faces, the gray handshakes of angels and the gray St. Peter's wall.

Trapeze artists and circuses are colorful and exciting, but they're acts. When his friend tells him that it's not meant to last, (perhaps even a breakup) he is crushed and suddenly the circus (his life) feels scary and dangerous. He is angered by the shattered illusion. This is the memory he prefers to be seldom recalled.

The misery during his life made him lose "all he wanted." He compares himself to a dog who chases rain and trains--things that are too fleeting to tangibly catch. He asks "who the hell can see forever?" One cannot see forever while "running circles round the well," instead of in a straight line. He wanted to hold onto life so badly that it slipped out of his grasp. Because he couldn't accept death, he couldn't fully accept life, only an illusion of it.

He realizes that the best times were the ones spent counting the passage of things, with rug burns and with bruises.

In the last verse, he is finally letting go, albeit reluctantly. He is unsure about making the pearly gates(how could it compare to the colorful circus?) He has a cartoonish vision of pearly gates, Lucifer, God and angels who kiss on sinners. If he is able to accept the existence of these then his heaven might possibly include carnival-esque things like monkeys and marching bands. How fitting that he uses the word "finally" in his last request to be remembered.

JD said...

This song makes me cry every time I give it a good listen.

I see the narrator as a ghost or a soul in some sort of purgatory who is on the brink letting go and moving to the next step, which he thinks of as a cliche version of heaven.

There are three characteristics of a trapeze swinger that are used throughout the song: swinging, being up high, and being colorful like a circus.

Like a trapeze swinger, he takes comfort in going perpetually back and forth, without the finality of an ending. He mentions several examples in the memories he wants his friend/lover to recall. "That season left the world and then returned." Autumn signals death but spring always comes again. The Halloween costumes in which they had "forgotten one another" seemed silly when morning came. Other cyclical words/phrases are: "we'll meet again," "Lost and Found,and "running in circles round the well."

Also like a trapeze swinger, he takes comfort in being up high. He likes things that are out of focus or out of reach because they seem to lack the finality that he dreads. The far away road at happy hour "leaves" but it was okay because it was too far away to see clearly. He likes the memory of childhood quest with the piggy bank and the map, because the final destination was "too removed to mention." Cars and trains can flit by and it's okay because he can't see where they end.

Cleverly, there are several words/phrases chosen for their locations (either being up high or down low, like heaven or earth.) Low: rug-burned, empty road, parking lot, below the hill, fallen trees, and rose bush. High: much too high, tallest tower, hill, mountain range, don't look down, swing as high, and birds above there.

A trapeze swinger would be drawn to color like the neon graffiti paint or colorful birds. To the narrator, things representing death are bleak and monochromatic. Such as black cars, white Halloween (death) faces, the gray handshakes of angels and the gray St. Peter's wall.

Trapeze artists and circuses are colorful and exciting, but they're acts. When his friend tells him that it's not meant to last, (perhaps even a breakup) he is crushed and suddenly the circus (his life) feels scary and dangerous. He is angered by the shattered illusion. This is the memory he prefers to be seldom recalled.

The misery during his life made him lose "all he wanted." He compares himself to a dog who chases rain and trains--things that are too fleeting to tangibly catch. He asks "who the hell can see forever?" One cannot see forever while "running circles round the well," instead of in a straight line. He wanted to hold onto life so badly that it slipped out of his grasp. Because he couldn't accept death, he couldn't fully accept life, only an illusion of it.

He realizes that the best times were the ones spent counting the passage of things, with rug burns and with bruises.

In the last verse, he is finally letting go, albeit reluctantly. He is unsure about making the pearly gates(how could it compare to the colorful circus?) He has a cartoonish vision of pearly gates, Lucifer, God and angels who kiss on sinners. If he is able to accept the existence of these then his heaven might possibly include carnival-esque things like monkeys and marching bands. How fitting that he uses the word "finally" in his last request to be remembered.

Shawn said...

Thanks for sharing JD, and everyone really. I'm always surprised at the amount of random traffic this post gets.

Anonymous said...

well, the song runs about 9 minutes and a half, and that's quite long, for a song..but i never stop wanting to hear it over and over again. at first i really don't know the lyrics, i just love hearing it, but then i got curious about it and then found out that the lyrics is quite complicated, it has deeper meaning. And so as i go over it again, and this time with the lyrics, i try to think what it's real meaning. For me this song is about leaving....departing...dying. The pearly gates for me is the Heaven. and he said we'll meet again. My interpretation is that the guy is dying and he wanted to be remembered by the woman he loves. in the last line of the lyrics he said Please, remember me
Finally
And all my uphill clawing
My dear
But if i make
The pearly gates
Do my best to make a drawing
Of G-d and Lucifer
A boy and girl
An angel kissin on a sinner
A monkey and a man
A marching band
All around the frightened trapeze swingers
if he makes at the pearly gates he'll do his best to describe Heaven for her....And he even mention remember me in Halloween. I think that's the whole meaning of a song.

Anonymous said...

Someone special from my past sent me this song and I've been listening to it over and over trying to figure it out. There is one part that I think I may understand.
In the end, the part about making a drawing. I think he's likening them to God and Lucifer, Boy and Girl, etc. Like he believes himself to be so flawed, almost unworthy and she is the angel "kissing on a sinner".
He wants to leave some part of what they were on the Pearly Gates, where they'll stay forever and that's his way of making what can't last at least be remembered.
Just my two cents...

Yjstripedblue said...

Was I the only one who thought that the speaker was killed by the vicious circus dogs, or at least fell into the well that was brought up in the previous stanza, and that is why he is singing the entire song as a dead person?

Yes, "trapeze swinger" or "trapeze act" means so many different things. I agree that this song is less about the story and more about the mood, as a lot of the words are uttered as fragments just to add onto the mood. Which makes the complete "understanding" of the song quite impossible. But I'm sure we can each get closer to understanding the song if we keep listening to it over and over again. Probably impossible to say "this is exactly what this song means and only this."

Not always, but sometimes I have my impatient moments; yes, I do get driven crazy by songs like this at those times.

Yjstripedblue said...

Was I the only one who thought that the speaker was killed by the vicious circus dogs, or at least fell into the well that was brought up in the previous stanza, and that is why he is singing the entire song as a dead person?

Yes, "trapeze swinger" or "trapeze act" means so many different things. I agree that this song is less about the story and more about the mood, as a lot of the words are uttered as fragments just to add onto the mood. Which makes the complete "understanding" of the song quite impossible. But I'm sure we can each get closer to understanding the song if we keep listening to it over and over again. Probably impossible to say "this is exactly what this song means and only this."

Not always, but sometimes I have my impatient moments; yes, I do get driven crazy by songs like this at those times.

Anonymous said...

I think the 'rude' guy was annoyed by you saying: "Being a gracious host I will now explain it. This is what the song means..."

Did you write the song??

Shawn said...

You maybe should read the rest of the sentence you partially quoted. Oh Snap!!!!!!!!

Graham said...

OK I Think the lyrics are all chosen for rhythmic effect. The theme of dying before someone else runs heavily through iron and wine music but after reading everyone's comments I'm starting to think this song is less litteral as I had previously though. However, it will always make me think.

This is a few of things it made me think about.

The graffiti I think has no meaning bar irony. Maybe also depicting that no matter what you vision of a place or even a paradise may be it will always be somewhat tainted. I also think of the thoughts behind it. People waiting for judgement and just thought to take the time to put a little humour on the walls to ease the tension for future "judgees" these comic musings are the thing that makes me love the song. However because of my view of these I think youR ideas of what they mean Are irrelivent to me. As I think it's a case of he has heard that this is the case, from who is not stated and why he knows is not stated but it's the same person that said the girl is still beautiful, that's all we know.

He does say that if he gets there he will make his own graffiti as a message to her, implying that he thinks he will get there before her. He may not be dead yet but it's likely.

I love the graffiti reference and I love the feel, but as with a lot of iron and wine songs, they are carefully constructed to make you think, but not entirely designed with a solid meaning, a healthy dose of religious imagery and rhythmic structures, it's safe to assume that the song is designed to have an open meaning, by which it is to mean what ever you want it to mean, so long as it does what it's supposed to capture your heart from the very first hearing, but still remain interesting time and time again.

Does anyone get the impression that the whole thing is just imagery, I.e not litteral at all, he's not a trapeze swinger at all. I don't know anything and probably know a little as everyone else but I love how much this song makes people think, which makes me sad when I here modern pop songs, as this should be what music is about. Music should always be a subject of debate and question, but what can you devise from I love you like a love song baby. ..........NOTHING! Drivvel!

Anonymous said...

I interpreted it as a man's suicide note, left before he jumped from "the tallest tower"
His life is flashing before his eyes, time stretched before him as he contemplates his death. He sees all the mistakes and coincidences and things that happened that caused the distance between him and the woman he loves.
As I see it, his suicide is over unrequited love.

Anonymous said...

Greetings fellow seekers... Interesting discussion... I humbly submit the whole song is a coherent tale of a man in purgatory who committed suicide by jumping out of a tall building... the song is his note to various people. I came to this understanding after a profound experience. I made a site of a complete lyric breakdown and how I came to the understanding. You can check it out here....

https://thetrapezeswingersite.wordpress.com/the-trapeze-swinger-lyrics-meaning/

If you are troubled, seek the spiritual and Gleam and Resonate...